Issue Insight

View Original

Counterintuitive?  The hostages held by Hamas and other parties in Gaza are the only buffer, the only preventative to further intense destruction of Gaza and civilian deaths in Gaza.

Counterintuitive?  The hostages held by Hamas and other parties in Gaza are the only buffer, the only preventative to further intense destruction of Gaza and civilian deaths in Gaza. 

As perverse as that reads, the civilian population of Gaza may be safer if there are hostages in Gaza.  No hostages, no reason for restraint by the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) as they pursue Hamas.

Absent hostages known or believed to be in Gaza, the government of the State of Israel will have few impediments to directing the IDF to leveling the structural landscape in Gaza with a singular purpose of killing members of Hamas, supporters of Hamas, and members and supporters of organizations with connectivity to Hamas.

If the government of the State of Israel was singularly focused upon release of hostages, it could have and publicly said it would release (trade) all incarcerated Palestinians and those with Hamas connectivity- an exchange of approximately 6,000 for approximately 240 (Hamas has reported fifty hostages deceased due to IDF activities).

Once there are no hostages in Gaza, the IDF will not take their tanks and bulldozers and go home.  Meaning the residents of Gaza will continue to have no homes to go to.

LINKS To Related Analyses

11/13/23- Shocked! Biden Administration Refrains Saying Israel Should Pay For Gaza Destruction. “[C]onversations with partners in the region about that very question” But Not Naming Israel And Its $200 Billion.

11/5/23- Why Israel, $522 Billion GDP- World’s 29th Largest; $23.6 Billion Defense Budget- World’s 11th Largest; $200 Billion Foreign Reserves- World’s 18th Largest; Needs $14.3 Billion From U.S. Taxpayers?

10/30/23- Biden-Harris Administration Requesting US$43.74 Per Person For Gaza And US$1,474.22 Per Person For Israel. Who Has The Greater Per Person Immediate Need?

10/25/23- Now We Know Official Plans For “Day After” In Gaza By Government Of Israel. Palestinians Get Two-States. But, Not As Desired. They May Be Separated. Should Supporters Embrace “Two-State-Light”?

10/15/23- Why Shouldn’t Israel Be Held To “You Break It, You Own It” Pottery Barn Rule For Destruction Of Gaza? US, EU Say Russia Should Pay To Rebuild Ukraine. Israel Has US$200 Billion In Foreign Reserves.